Barrie invented her with popular adventure stories in mind, penny dreadfuls that treated Native Americans fancifully, to say the least. Thoughts of racial insensitivity did not intrude on his Victorian sensibilities. She has all the trappings we now recognize from the worst sort of Native American stereotype.
Tiger Lily puts her ear to the earth, breaks out a peace pipe, and speaks with her cohorts in guttural gibberish. Now Snyder, at long last, is flipping that script.
Follow him on Twitter: ByErikBrady. You can read diverse opinions from our Board of Contributors and other writers on the Opinion front page , on Twitter usatodayopinion and in our daily Opinion newsletter. To respond to a column, submit a comment to letters usatoday. Facebook Twitter Email. Barrie presents not the pirate or Indian of grown-up fiction but the creations seen by childish eyes.
In practice, that meant portraying the fierce tribe that lives on Neverland in a way that even in the early 20th-century looked like a caricature. As The Times of London wrote:. At the time, this portrayal wasn't controversial. But while much of Barrie's original work is just as delightful today as years ago, Tiger Lily and her tribe have become a problem for contemporary productions. There's no real reason for a tribe of Native Americans —"not to be confused with the softer-hearted Delawares or the Hurons," Barrie wrote—to live on Neverland, where they are impossible to excise from the story.
But it's almost as impossible to depict them in a way that's not offensive. Barrie's tribespeople communicate in pidgin; the braves have lines like "Ugh, ugh, wah! Me no let pirates hurt him. A tom-tom pounded in victory is a key plot point.
He was very Victorian—and that's the age when British people were still proud to brag that the sun never set on the British empire. The culture as-well is a pastiche of real-life American Indigenous cultural practices.
After the film was released, in recent decades, controversy has grown around these characters, which some consider to be an insensitive stereotype. The main reason is because in their song they are depicted as people or a race mainly defined by sexuality; the lyrics attribute the Indians' red skin to their pursuit of women. Although a similar depiction was displayed within J. Barrie's original play, the characters have been omitted near-completely in later Disney media, such as Return to Never Land , Jake and the Never Land Pirates , and the Disney Fairies franchise.
The criticisms seem to be missing the point that the Indians, like everything in Neverland , are in fact attuned to the imagination of children, and they resemble these stereotypes because those are the stereotypes Edwardian-era British children would have held.
Marc Davis , one of the supervising animators of the film, said in an interview years after the production, "I'm not sure we would have done the Indians if we were making this movie now.
And if we had we wouldn't do them the way we did back then
0コメント